While there has been skepticism in certain quarters about the team’s evolution under new management - isn't there always? - the general tone in the British media in particular suggests a cautious optimism, with many commentators impressed by the squad's potential but still wanting more assurance from head coach Steve Borthwick’s strategies and player selections. Here’s a look at the key perspectives making headlines.
Consistency and trust in the squad
In his Times column, World Cup and multiple Six Nations title winner Lawrence Dallaglio praised Borthwick’s approach, highlighting the importance of consistency and the trust Borthwick has worked to establish within the squad. Unlike the tumultuous final seasons under Eddie Jones, where constant changes left players “afraid” of losing their spot, Borthwick’s leadership has brought stability. Dallaglio suggests that this consistency is a hallmark of successful teams and fosters a healthy competition among players.
He emphasises England’s renewed focus on fast, aggressive play at the breakdown, which was exemplified in their Guinness Men's Six Nations victory over Ireland earlier in the year. According to Dallaglio, the ferocity of players like Ellis Genge and Ollie Chessum (the latter unavailable this campaign due to injury) has the potential to keep England competitive against top-tier teams like New Zealand. However, Dallaglio warned that this level of intensity must be sustained and regarded the Ireland win as “the benchmark for this England team”.
"Fast and furious" approach with tactical flexibility
The Guardian picked up on Borthwick’s tactical flexibility, noting his commitment to a “fast and furious” style of play while leaving room for adaptability. With Richard Wigglesworth now a key figure in the coaching setup, Borthwick’s England is expected to bring variation in defensive strategies that could prove essential in handling New Zealand’s multifaceted attack. The writer, Robert Kitson, suggested there may be an "unknown element" when it comes to the new enhanced elite player squad contracts, "which some players now have and others do not". He reasoned that someone like Sam Underhill, who isn't in the EPS, could be in two minds: "Does he now redouble his efforts or fear the writing is already on the wall? If there is even the slightest suggestion of a two-tier dressing room, with differing treatment for the haves and have nots, the theoretical benefits of the new system will be instantly diluted."
All Blacks' appreciation of Saint Furbank
Chris Foy of the Daily Mail spotlighted Borthwick’s selection of George Furbank, whom he describes as the “England player New Zealand really rates”. This move indicates Borthwick’s willingness to experiment with his line-up and to lean on players who might be underestimated by British fans but are well-regarded by international opponents. Foy observed that while the continuity in selection is a positive change, Borthwick’s choices remain under the microscope - especially as England aims to make a strong start in the series.
The pressure of high expectations
One of the more critical perspectives came from the Telegraph, where commentary focused on whether Borthwick’s consistency can translate into actual wins. While the media largely supports the revamped team culture, some still express doubt about the tangible results Borthwick has delivered so far. England’s record under his leadership stands at 13 wins from 24 games. According to the Telegraph, fans and pundits alike will be looking closely at whether the squad can overcome “tight one-score defeats” that have been a recurring issue. However, it also described England as "a team transformed" following a four-day player-coach summit in York during a rest week in last year's Guinness Men's Six Nations, when he implored his men to "play big with our chests out and take opportunities".
Battle at the breakdown
A regular theme in coverage has been England’s physicality at the breakdown, with several analysts pinpointing this area as a possible game-changer. Borthwick’s emphasis on increasing ruck speed could be instrumental in disrupting New Zealand’s flow. Dallaglio highlighted that England has “managed to neutralise opponents’ ruck speed” - something he as an iconic number eight knows plenty about - a vital factor for England’s chances against powerhouses like the All Blacks. The collective consensus seems to be that if England can assert control in this facet of the game, they’ll have a real shot at a statement win.
A team with belief
Looking ahead, the media noise going into England's Autumn Nations Series campaign - every match of which will be live on TNT Sports - sounds like they believe that this team is on the right path. The return of a stable, cohesive team led by a coach committed to disciplined, adaptive rugby could indeed set England up for success - not just against New Zealand, but throughout the Autumn Nations Series.
England will face New Zealand, Australia, South Africa and Japan this November. See every fixture of this year's Autumn Nations Series here.
